Civil Rights & Constitutional Law
Emily Moreno invokes Ohio’s new anti-SLAPP law to seek dismissal of Congressman Max Miller’s...
May 27, 2026
Thursday, October 22, 2026

Congressman Max Miller says in a court filing that sharing an intimate image of his child was a matter of public concern. So does his lawyer. The image depicted the child's genitals.
CLEVELAND, OH – U.S. Representative Max Miller and his attorney Aaron Minc asked a federal court to dismiss a civil-rights lawsuit brought on behalf of Miller’s young daughter after the pair, along with two members of Miller’s congressional staff, allegedly published a nude image of the child online. Their motions advance two striking arguments: Miller and Minc characterize Miller’s social-media posts linking to documents containing the image as speech on a matter of public concern, while Minc contends that Miller, as the child’s parent, consented to the disclosure.
The lawsuit, R.M. v. Miller, et al., filed in the Federal District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, alleges that Miller and Minc were involved in making an unredacted, intimate image of the child accessible through a public Dropbox folder during an online campaign targeting the child’s mother, Emily Moreno. The family’s original complaint named Miller, Minc, and Minc LLC as defendants. The complaint, amended after Minc and Miller’s filings, also named Philip Poe, Miller’s congressional chief of staff, and Abigail Angelos, his congressional director of communications, as defendants.
Miller filed his motion to dismiss on October 1, 2026. He argued that his social-media posts linking to documents containing the image, which displays his daughter’s genitals, constituted speech on a matter of public concern.
“An action premised on the disclosure of that document, in that forum, for that purpose, is an action ‘relating to... a matter of public concern or public interest,’” Miller’s motion states.
Minc, too, argues that the image’s publication falls within a public-concern exemption: “Thus, the publication of the image is expressly exempt, in these circumstances, from liability under the statute as it relates to a matter of public concern or public interest.”
Neither Defendant explains how disclosing an image depicting a child’s genitals is even remotely in the public interest. Or even if it were, why they couldn't redact the genitals.
In Minc’s October 13, 2026 motion to dismiss, he also advances a parental-consent argument.
“As R.M.’s parent, Miller consented to the disclosure,” Minc’s motion says, referring to the intimate image.
Both defendants ask the court to dismiss R.M.’s lawsuit and order Moreno to pay the attorney fees they incurred defending against it under Ohio’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (UPEPA), which protects speech on a matter of public concern. The court has not ruled on their arguments.
Based on Miller’s accusations in a deposition during child-custody proceeding, the family’s amended complaint added Philip Poe, Miller’s congressional chief of staff, and Abigail Angelos, the congressman’s director of communications, as defendants, in their individual capacities. It alleges that they were involved in disseminating a publicly accessible Dropbox folder containing the child’s unredacted intimate image.
The amended complaint also expands the child’s claims, including additional claims under federal law concerning the disclosure of intimate images under 15 U.S.C. § 6851 and Ohio law.
According to the amended complaint, Miller provided Minc, Poe, and Angelos with documents and media files that the defendants then made accessible through a public Dropbox folder. The filing alleges that the folder contained an unredacted document featuring the child’s intimate image and the child’s name.
The amended complaint further alleges that Minc created and controlled the Dropbox folder, changing the settings to allow members of the public to edit its contents and restore the unredacted photo.
According to the filing, Minc admitted in correspondence regarding the unredacted release that he “was under an enormous amount of pressure to get the files and link live again as quickly as possible.” The complaint alleges that, in his reckless haste to assist Miller’s public-relations assault—and pressured by a furious Miller intent on maligning his ex-wife—Minc failed to properly redact the files containing the toddler’s nude image.
Miller, his staff, and his attorney shared the folder amid a firestorm of public backlash over allegations that Miller abused his former wife, Emily Moreno, and his daughter, the lawsuit alleges. Defendants published the folder after Miller went live on X.com to bash his ex-wife and urged viewers to “take a look at the documents” in the Dropbox folder, it alleges.
According to the filing, Miller’s two social-media posts, which Miller alleges his staff created, linking the public Dropbox folder generated more than 400,000 total views. Minc acknowledged in an email that the photo remained online for about 23 hours before being removed. The defendants’ actions exposed the child to serious and foreseeable harm, the complaint alleges.
Subodh Chandra, the family’s lead counsel, said the defendants’ arguments underscore the need to keep the child—not the adults’ dispute—at the center of the case:
Miller and Minc are asking a court to accept that the public had an interest in seeing an intimate image of a two-year-old child depicting her genitals. These arguments are as disturbing as they are revealing. A child’s intimate image does not become a matter of legitimate public interest just because adults are engaged in a personal or even a political dispute. Our client’s daughter deserves privacy, dignity, and protection—not to have displaying her genitals defended as something the public was concerned about seeing.
The case is pending in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio under the caption R.M. v. Miller et al., Case No. 1:26-cv-01899-MJH. The family is represented by Subodh Chandra and Emily Bohatch. The motions to dismiss are now moot because the complaint was amended.
"It will be interesting to see if the defendants persist in these absurd and seemingly shameless arguments," Chandra added.
At Chandra Law, your case is our cause.®
The Chandra Law Firm LLC is solely responsible for the content of this website.
©2026 The Chandra Law Firm LLC.